scaffolding #1

Merged
giteadmin merged 18 commits from scaffolding into main 2024-12-24 12:02:50 +00:00
10 changed files with 676 additions and 84 deletions
Showing only changes of commit e668fcf9a0 - Show all commits
+2 -2
View File
@@ -1,2 +1,2 @@
cache/
out/
onchain/cache/
onchain/out/
+3 -2
View File
@@ -1,3 +1,4 @@
[submodule "lib/forge-std"]
path = lib/forge-std
[submodule "onchain/lib/forge-std"]
path = onchain/lib/forge-std
url = https://github.com/foundry-rs/forge-std
+152
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,152 @@
// SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT
pragma solidity ^0.8.20;
import "forge-std/console.sol";
import {Push3Interpreter} from "../src/Push3Interpreter.sol";
/**
* @title Push3IntAdapter
* @dev An adapter contract for our Push3Interpreter that provides
* various integer-only I/O function overloads. We now create
* a SUBLIST descriptor for the entire code array, placing it
* on the EXEC stack. We ignore finalCodeStack/finalExecStack
* to avoid compiler warnings.
*/
contract Push3IntAdapter {
Push3Interpreter public interpreter;
constructor(address _interpreter) {
interpreter = Push3Interpreter(_interpreter);
}
/**
* @notice Utility function to build a single sublist descriptor
* covering the entire `code` array, offset=0, length=code.length.
*/
function _makeFullSublistDescriptor(bytes calldata code)
internal
view
returns (uint256)
{
// CodeTag.SUBLIST is typically enum = 3, but
// let's fetch it via
// (uint8)Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST
// or we can directly pass 3 if we know the numeric value.
// We'll do:
return interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST, // the tag
0, // offset
uint32(code.length), // length of entire code array
0 // leftover bits=0
);
}
/**
* @notice Single int input, single int output.
* 1) Build a sublist descriptor for the entire code,
* 2) Place that descriptor in the EXEC stack,
* 3) Preload `in1` on the integer stack,
* 4) Run the interpreter,
* 5) Return top of final int stack.
*/
function run1In1Out(bytes calldata code, int256 in1)
external
view
returns (int256 out1)
{
// 1) Build the sublist descriptor
uint256 fullDesc = _makeFullSublistDescriptor(code);
// 2) EXEC stack of size 1
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = fullDesc;
// No code stack
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
// 3) Preload int stack
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](1);
initIntStack[0] = in1;
// 4) Run
(, , int256[] memory finalIntStack) =
interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// 5) Return top of final int stack
require(finalIntStack.length > 0, "No integer output produced");
out1 = finalIntStack[finalIntStack.length - 1];
}
/**
* @notice Two ints input, single int output
*/
function run2In1Out(bytes calldata code, int256 in1, int256 in2)
external
view
returns (int256 out1)
{
uint256 fullDesc = _makeFullSublistDescriptor(code);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = fullDesc;
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](2);
initIntStack[0] = in1;
initIntStack[1] = in2;
(, , int256[] memory finalIntStack) =
interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
require(finalIntStack.length > 0, "No integer output");
out1 = finalIntStack[finalIntStack.length - 1];
}
/**
* @notice Single int input, two int outputs
*/
function run1In2Out(bytes calldata code, int256 in1)
external
view
returns (int256 out1, int256 out2)
{
uint256 fullDesc = _makeFullSublistDescriptor(code);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = fullDesc;
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](1);
initIntStack[0] = in1;
(, , int256[] memory finalIntStack) =
interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
require(finalIntStack.length >= 2, "Not enough outputs");
out1 = finalIntStack[finalIntStack.length - 1];
out2 = finalIntStack[finalIntStack.length - 2];
}
/**
* @notice Zero int input, returns entire final int stack
*/
function run0InNOut(bytes calldata code)
external
view
returns (int256[] memory)
{
uint256 fullDesc = _makeFullSublistDescriptor(code);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = fullDesc;
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
(, , int256[] memory finalIntStack) =
interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
return finalIntStack;
}
}
@@ -6,8 +6,7 @@ import "forge-std/console.sol";
/**
* @title Push3Interpreter
* @dev Demonstrates a minimal Push3-like interpreter that uses
* a token-based bytecode approach. We fix the assembly
* endianness issues by copying exact bytes for 2- and 4-byte reads.
* a token-based bytecode approach.
*/
contract Push3Interpreter {
// -----------------------------------------------------
@@ -22,7 +21,11 @@ contract Push3Interpreter {
enum OpCode {
NOOP, // 0
INTEGER_PLUS // 1
INTEGER_PLUS, // 1
INTEGER_MINUS, // 2
INTEGER_MULT, // 3
INTEGER_DUP, // 4
INTEGER_POP // 5
}
// -----------------------------------------------------
@@ -111,12 +114,15 @@ contract Push3Interpreter {
*/
function readUint16(bytes calldata code, uint32 start) internal pure returns (uint16 val) {
require(start + 2 <= code.length, "readUint16 out of range");
uint256 word;
assembly {
let buf := mload(0x40)
calldatacopy(buf, add(code.offset, start), 2)
let word := mload(buf)
word := mload(buf)
val := and(word, 0xffff)
}
// Not sure this is correct
val = uint16(word >> 240);
}
// -----------------------------------------------------
@@ -128,6 +134,7 @@ contract Push3Interpreter {
* 0x01 => INTEGER_PLUS
* 0x02 => INT_LITERAL => read next 4 bytes => int32
* 0x03 => SUBLIST => read next 2 bytes => subLen => parse that
* 0x04 => INTEGER_MINUS
*/
function parseSublist(bytes calldata code, uint32 off, uint32 len)
internal
@@ -187,6 +194,24 @@ contract Push3Interpreter {
break;
}
}
else if (tokenType == 0x04) {
// INTEGER_PLUS
temp[count] = makeInstruction(OpCode.INTEGER_MINUS);
count++;
}
else if (tokenType == 0x05) {
// INTEGER_PLUS
temp[count] = makeInstruction(OpCode.INTEGER_MULT);
count++;
}
else if (tokenType == 0x06) {
temp[count] = makeInstruction(OpCode.INTEGER_DUP);
count++;
}
else if (tokenType == 0x07) {
temp[count] = makeInstruction(OpCode.INTEGER_POP);
count++;
}
else {
// unknown => NOOP
temp[count] = makeInstruction(OpCode.NOOP);
@@ -260,6 +285,38 @@ contract Push3Interpreter {
intTop++;
}
}
else if (op == OpCode.INTEGER_MINUS) {
// pop top 2 => minus
if (intTop >= 2) {
int256 a = intStack[intTop - 1];
int256 b = intStack[intTop - 2];
intTop -= 2;
intStack[intTop] = b - a;
intTop++;
}
}
else if (op == OpCode.INTEGER_MULT) {
// pop top 2 => minus
if (intTop >= 2) {
int256 a = intStack[intTop - 1];
int256 b = intStack[intTop - 2];
intTop -= 2;
intStack[intTop] = b * a;
intTop++;
}
}
else if (op == OpCode.INTEGER_DUP) {
if (intTop >= 1) {
int256 a = intStack[intTop - 1];
intStack[intTop] = a;
intTop++;
}
}
else if (op == OpCode.INTEGER_POP) {
if (intTop >= 1) {
intTop -= 1;
}
}
}
else if (tag == CodeTag.INT_LITERAL) {
int32 val = extractInt32(topDesc);
+81
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,81 @@
// SPDX-License-Identifier: UNLICENSED
pragma solidity ^0.8.20;
import {Test} from "forge-std/Test.sol";
import {Push3Interpreter} from "../src/Push3Interpreter.sol";
import {Push3IntAdapter} from "../src/Push3IntAdapter.sol";
/**
* @title Push3IntAdapterTest
* @dev Foundry test for the Push3IntAdapter contract,
* which composes with the Push3Interpreter.
*/
contract Push3IntAdapterTest is Test {
Push3Interpreter public interpreter;
Push3IntAdapter public adapter;
function setUp() public {
// 1) Deploy the interpreter
interpreter = new Push3Interpreter();
// 2) Deploy the adapter, referencing the interpreter address
adapter = new Push3IntAdapter(address(interpreter));
}
/**
* @notice Test run1In1Out with a minimal code array.
* For example, we might do a program that just leaves its input unchanged
* (like a NOOP).
*/
function test_run1In1Out_noop() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"03000100";
int256 inputVal = 123;
int256 result = adapter.run1In1Out(code, inputVal);
// We expect the code does nothing => output == input
assertEq(result, inputVal, "Expected same value out");
}
/**
* @notice Test run2In1Out. We'll push 5, 7, do an op that leaves 12.
*/
function test_run2In1Out_plus() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"03000101";
int256 in1 = 5;
int256 in2 = 7;
int256 result = adapter.run2In1Out(code, in1, in2);
assertEq(result, 12, "Expected 5 + 7 = 12");
}
/**
* @notice Test run1In2Out. Push a constant to a stack with 1.
* For now, we do a placeholder code.
*/
function test_run1In2Out() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"0300050200000003";
int256 inVal = 42;
(int256 top, int256 secondTop) = adapter.run1In2Out(code, inVal);
assertEq(top, 3, "top stack val mismatch");
assertEq(secondTop, 42, "second top stack val mismatch");
}
/**
* @notice Test run0InNOut.
* We'll feed a code that pushes some constants, and see the final stack.
*/
function test_run0InNOut() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"03000A02000000030200000005";
int256[] memory stackResult = adapter.run0InNOut(code);
assertEq(stackResult.length, 2, "Expected 2 final stack items");
assertEq(stackResult[0], 3, "Item 0 mismatch");
assertEq(stackResult[1], 5, "Item 1 mismatch");
}
}
+376
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,376 @@
// SPDX-License-Identifier: UNLICENSED
pragma solidity ^0.8.20;
import {Test} from "forge-std/Test.sol";
import "forge-std/console.sol";
import {Push3Interpreter} from "../src/Push3Interpreter.sol";
/**
* @title Push3InterpreterTest
* @dev Foundry test contract for the updated Push3Interpreter
*/
contract Push3InterpreterTest is Test {
Push3Interpreter public interpreter;
function setUp() public {
interpreter = new Push3Interpreter();
}
/**
* @notice Test a small program that:
* 1) Pushes literal 10 (int32)
* 2) Pushes literal 32 (int32)
* 3) Calls INTEGER_PLUS
*
* We'll store everything in a single SUBLIST:
* 0x03 => SUBLIST
* 0x00 0x0B => subLen=11
* Then the next 11 bytes are:
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 0A) => INT_LITERAL(10)
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 20) => INT_LITERAL(32)
* 0x01 => INTEGER_PLUS
*
* So total = 1 + 2 + (1+4 + 1+4 + 1) = 14 bytes
* => 0x03 00 0B 02 00 00 00 0A 02 00 00 00 20 01
*/
function test_LiteralsAndPlus() public view {
// The final code array (14 bytes):
// [0] = 0x03
// [1..2] = 0x000B
// [3] = 0x02
// [4..7] = 0x0000000A => 10
// [8] = 0x02
// [9..12] = 0x00000020 => 32
// [13] = 0x01 => plus
bytes memory code = hex"03000B020000000A020000002001";
// Or fully concatenated:
// 0x03 00 0B 02 00 00 00 0A 02 00 00 00 20 01
// We'll parse offset=0, length=14
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0, // offset
14, // length
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run it
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Should produce finalIntStack = [42]
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 1, "finalIntStack should have length 1");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], 42, "Should be 10+32=42");
}
/**
* @notice Test pushing literal 10, literal 3, then INTEGER_MINUS => (10 - 3) = 7
*
* The plan:
* 0x03 => SUBLIST token
* 0x00 0x0B => subLen=11
*
* Then 11 bytes:
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 0A) => INT_LITERAL(10)
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 03) => INT_LITERAL(3)
* 0x04 => INTEGER_MINUS (assuming 0x04 is assigned to minus)
*/
function test_Minus() public view {
// We'll produce 14 total bytes, same structure as the plus example
// Format: [0x03, 0x000B, 0x02(10), 0x03(3), 0x04 => minus]
bytes memory code = hex"03000B020000000A020000000304";
// Breaking it down:
// 0x03 => SUBLIST
// 0x00 0x0B => length=11
// 0x02 0000000A => INT_LITERAL(10)
// 0x02 00000003 => INT_LITERAL(3)
// 0x04 => INTEGER_MINUS
// We'll parse offset=0, length=14
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0, // offset
14, // length
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Check final result => should be [7]
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 1, "finalIntStack should have length 1");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], 7, "Should be 10 - 3 = 7");
}
/**
* @notice Test pushing literal 10, literal 3, then INTEGER_MULT => (10 * 3) = 30
*
* The plan:
* 0x03 => SUBLIST token
* 0x00 0x0B => subLen=11
*
* Then 11 bytes:
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 0A) => INT_LITERAL(10)
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 03) => INT_LITERAL(3)
* 0x05 => INTEGER_MULT
*/
function test_Mult() public view {
// We'll produce 14 total bytes, same structure as the plus example
// Format: [0x03, 0x000B, 0x02(10), 0x03(3), 0x05 => mul]
bytes memory code = hex"03000B020000000A020000000305";
// Breaking it down:
// 0x03 => SUBLIST
// 0x00 0x0B => length=11
// 0x02 0000000A => INT_LITERAL(10)
// 0x02 00000003 => INT_LITERAL(3)
// 0x05 => INTEGER_MUL
// We'll parse offset=0, length=14
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0, // offset
14, // length
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Check final result => should be [30]
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 1, "finalIntStack should have length 1");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], 30, "Should be 10 * 3 = 30");
}
function test_Dup() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"030006020000000A06";
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0,
9,
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 2, "finalIntStack should have length 1");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], finalIntStack[1], "The top 2 values on the stack should be equal.");
}
function test_Pop() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"030006020000000A07";
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0,
9,
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 0, "finalIntStack should be empty");
}
/**
* @notice Test with an unknown token (0xF0).
* We expect the parser to treat it as "unknown => NOOP"
* and produce a NOOP instruction descriptor.
* We'll confirm finalIntStack remains empty (or unchanged).
*/
function test_UnknownToken() public view {
// We'll create a 5-byte code:
// 0x03 => SUBLIST
// 0x00 0x01 => length=1
// 0xF0 => unknown token
bytes memory code = hex"030001F0";
// We'll parse offset=0, length=4
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0, // offset
4, // length
0
);
// init stacks
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// finalIntStack should remain empty => no literal was pushed
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 0, "Expected finalIntStack to remain empty with unknown token => NOOP");
}
/**
* @notice Test a partial literal: we claim to have 4 bytes, but the code array ends early.
* This should trigger the `else { break; }` branch in parseSublist
* when trying to read 4 bytes for the INT_LITERAL.
*/
function test_OutOfRangeLiteral() public view {
// 0x03 => SUBLIST
// 0x00 0x04 => length=4
// 0x02 => INT_LITERAL token
// Then we have only 1 byte left instead of 4 => insufficient
//
// total = 1 + 2 + 1 + 1 = 5 bytes
// The parser tries to read 4 bytes after seeing 0x04, fails, hits break.
bytes memory code = hex"03000402FF";
// parse offset=0, length=5
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0,
5,
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Because the parse breaks early, we expect finalIntStack is empty or unchanged
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 0, "Expected parse to break on out-of-range literal => no ints pushed");
}
/**
* @notice Test "not enough int args" scenario:
* We'll push only 1 literal, then do INTEGER_PLUS which needs 2 integers on the stack.
* In the main loop, it sees intTop < 2 => it does nothing.
*/
function test_NotEnoughIntArgs() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"030006020000000305";
// Breaking it down:
// 0x03 => SUBLIST
// 0x00 0x06 => length=6
// 0x02 00000003 => INT_LITERAL(3)
// 0x05 => INTEGER_MUL
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0,
9,
0
);
// set up stacks
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// We expect finalIntStack => [5],
// because the PLUS instruction sees only 1 int => does nothing => 5 remains
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 1, "Should have 1 int left");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], 3, "Expected stack top=3 after insufficient-args plus");
}
/**
* @notice Test sublist length overflow:
* subLen claims bigger than the code array. Should trigger else { break; }
* in the sublist parsing for that sublist.
*/
function test_SublistLengthOverflow() public view {
bytes memory code = hex"050010FFFFFF";
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0,
6,
0
);
// init
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
(
,
,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Expect no items pushed => finalIntStack empty
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 0, "Expected empty stack if sublist length is out of range => parse break");
}
}
-75
View File
@@ -1,75 +0,0 @@
// SPDX-License-Identifier: UNLICENSED
pragma solidity ^0.8.20;
import {Test} from "forge-std/Test.sol";
import {Push3Interpreter} from "../src/Push3Interpreter.sol";
/**
* @title Push3InterpreterTest
* @dev Foundry test contract for the updated Push3Interpreter
*/
contract Push3InterpreterTest is Test {
Push3Interpreter public interpreter;
function setUp() public {
interpreter = new Push3Interpreter();
}
/**
* @notice Test a small program that:
* 1) Pushes literal 10 (int32)
* 2) Pushes literal 32 (int32)
* 3) Calls INTEGER_PLUS
*
* We'll store everything in a single SUBLIST:
* 0x03 => SUBLIST
* 0x00 0x0B => subLen=11
* Then the next 11 bytes are:
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 0A) => INT_LITERAL(10)
* 0x02 + (00 00 00 20) => INT_LITERAL(32)
* 0x01 => INTEGER_PLUS
*
* So total = 1 + 2 + (1+4 + 1+4 + 1) = 14 bytes
* => 0x03 00 0B 02 00 00 00 0A 02 00 00 00 20 01
*/
function test_LiteralsAndPlus() public {
// The final code array (14 bytes):
// [0] = 0x03
// [1..2] = 0x000B
// [3] = 0x02
// [4..7] = 0x0000000A => 10
// [8] = 0x02
// [9..12] = 0x00000020 => 32
// [13] = 0x01 => plus
bytes memory code = hex"03000B020000000A020000002001";
// Or fully concatenated:
// 0x03 00 0B 02 00 00 00 0A 02 00 00 00 20 01
// We'll parse offset=0, length=14
uint256 sublistDesc = interpreter.makeDescriptor(
Push3Interpreter.CodeTag.SUBLIST,
0, // offset
14, // length
0
);
uint256[] memory initCodeStack = new uint256[](0);
uint256[] memory initExecStack = new uint256[](1);
initExecStack[0] = sublistDesc;
int256[] memory initIntStack = new int256[](0);
// Run it
(
uint256[] memory finalCodeStack,
uint256[] memory finalExecStack,
int256[] memory finalIntStack
) = interpreter.runInterpreter(code, initCodeStack, initExecStack, initIntStack);
// Should produce finalIntStack = [42]
assertEq(finalIntStack.length, 1, "finalIntStack should have length 1");
assertEq(finalIntStack[0], 42, "Should be 10+32=42");
}
}